I really like this set! The mechanics and interactions are interesting, and it also seems a clear step in the direction of toning down the power level of cards. Removal is decent, with black having 7 and 8 mana removal spells, and a lot of relevant cards have been kept in common or uncommon. In addition, it seems like each colour has a better defined identity, which I really like.
More importantly, the mythics are decent, but not really so overwhelming that you will go “well, they have that card, guess I lose”. Something like angel of sanctification is really really powerful, but you wont be hopelessly behind if you haven’t spent 39,99$ to buy it. Most mythics seem to follow this trend: They are good, but not overpowering, kudos!
Also, there are a lot of really bad cards, like pretty much all the rare trials, but I am fine with that, not every card needs to be super powerful, especially in a game where not everyone can acquire them.
The gods also seem very fair, although the white one is incredibly nasty. It is ironic that what has been deemed the worst god in paper, is the best god in puzzlequest by far in my opinion.
Support removal is at a good price, but cycling seems insanely powerful. Many of the cycling cards are cards that are mediocre or bad if cast normally, but insanely powerful if you cycle. To give an example:
1 mana: gain 5 life, draw a card.
That is INSANELY good!
It also seems that Black is the best colour in the set BY FAR, they have some commons that could easily be rares in other sets. I mean, a 2 mana 2/2 that draws a card, which can also be a straight up 7 mana 6/6? Not what I expected at uncommon! Or how about a 5 mana 4/5 with a drawback that can easily be bypassed?
In addition, I feel like you have done a good job of keeping Sarkhan and Arlinn kord relevant planeswalkers, simply due to the cards they will be able to combine, which i really like!
Overall, I feel that while this might be a relatively weak set compared to the set of puzzlequest, it is a really well designed set, and I consider it a bonus that it bring the power level a little back down to earth, meaning that new players with few rares or mythics will still have a decent shot at competing!
Well done! Pass my congratulations to the design team @LakeStone!