This really isn’t a hugely important thing, but it seems like it would be easy to do, so I’ll ask. I’d love it if every Planeswalker that’s available to play in Puzzle Quest were also available as a profile picture. My in-game name is Elspeth, and it’s weird seeing that next to a picture of Ajani (even though Elspeth would probably approve of her bestie filling in for her).
I think they should have every in-game card available as an avatar as well.
Also, every out of game card available as an avatar. They can get them all from gatherer.wizards.com.
Also, I think it’d be neat if they let people pay to use ANY picture they liked as an avatar. Make it $10 or so, and moderate the submission just to make sure nobody submits anything offensive.
I hadn’t checked the available avatars for a while, so I do see a handful that aren’t some kind of head or face be it human or animal. Definitely seems that the VIP membership unlocks a lot more non-sentient items as avatars. The majority still are some kind of head.