Sigarda, Heron's grace hex proof

[Claimh]

The text for Sigarda mentions that a Hexproof evergreen will be given to all humans including the planes walker. This hex proof erroneously disappears when Sigarda is removed. The planes walker is not hex proof.

If the hex proof is intended to be removed when Sigarda is removed, the text for Sigarda should say, “While Sigarda is on the battlefield, you and each human you control gain hex proof.”

[wereotter]

As far as the player character being hexproof, I think it was determined that it is working, but it’s a rather useless ability. Things like Whispers of Emrakul don’t target you, so they still go through, same thing for Origins Chandra’s first and third abilities. It really just prevents cards like Exquisite Firecraft from being able to hit you.