Why bad cards exist

MTGPQ Masterpieces have next to nothing in common with MTG Masterpieces.

The goal of Masterpieces in paper is to give highly sought-after cards for long-time players while at the same time lower the cost of the standard format for new players. (They can open them and trade them for other cards. Many boxes will be opened by players, lowering the cost of the rares, mythics, as more will be in circulation.)

In MTGPQ, Masterpieces are supposed to be the endgame, at the very top of what the players can hope to achieve in this game,

In Paper, you have many formats with different goals for the various types of players: casual (commander, tribal, theme), competitive (limited, constructed). You can even have competitive commander players, casual limited players, etc. In short, there is an amazing number of types of players.

In PQ, even if you are a casual or competitive player, your goal is the same, to get as many cards as possible, and as good as possible. What does it mean to be a casual player in PQ? Only your frequency of playing the game will change and you may not care as much for the objectives as other players.

In paper, I can blissfully play at the kitchen table, with my Angel deck, unaware of the real competition in the world. In PQ, events and rankings are always shoved down my throat, as it wants to trigger my competitive spirit.

It’s like the only way to play the game would be to go to the store, and play against tournament decks, while the shop owner keep shouting about the incredible rewards of finishing first and presenting the winners to the whole shop. You can try to play your casual Angel deck with a friend for a while, but you can’t ignore forever your surroundings. Some may compare Story Mode to the kitchen table far from the rest of the world, and they would be right for a while, but we have a really limited Story Mode in PQ, you can’t play it forever, and like I said they are always teasing you with the awesome prizes of outside.

The closer we have to formats are the different events (take “closer” with a grain of salt, it’s still light years from the formats), like Fate is Really Fair, where you need to summon 5 vehicles. When you play a given format, it’s to have fun in that restricted area, like in limited you open packs, and try to build the best deck you can with those scarce resources. Unfortunately, in PQ, while you are playing your limited deck, you may very well be paired against a Vintage deck (it’s the only format where the Power 9 are allowed, it’s the highest-powered format in magic), you have a lot of chances of losing and you won’t feel like it was a fair fight. Also, the other keyword is fun, summoning 5 vehicles is the opposite of fun.

So playing in events like Fate is really Fair is closer in analogy to playing a limited deck against a Vintage deck while getting repeatedly tazed in the Mana Jewels.

Sorry for my digression, what I wanted to say is that we don’t have multiple formats in PQ where cards would be valued differently for the players. You can’t build a tribal deck here and challenge your friend’s theme deck for fun. You’ll be facing the same opponents (in PvE and PvP), said decks are not meant for you to let your creativity flow. They are there to destroy you. You can only pursue one thing also in this game, cards and more cards.

That’s the direction that MTGPQ took, Rares are meant to be better than Uncommons, Mythic rares are better than rare, and Masterpieces should be at the pinnacle of power. Yet most are only Mythic in power, some are even worse than Uncommons as discussed in other threads. We can’t apply paper logic for the Masterpieces. It makes no sense for Masterpieces like Ornithopter and Lightning Greaves to be this underpowered.

One huge mistake that Richard Garfield made when he first designed Magic was thinking that you could balance the power of a card by making it rare. Ancestral Recall is from the same cycle as Lightning Bolt, Dark Ritual, Giant Growth and Healing Salve, but the other 4 cards are common, and the Ancestral Recall is rare. The idea was that most Magic players would buy maybe one 60-card starter deck and 2 or 3 15-card booster packs, and that would be their entire lifetime expenditure. Nobody (they thought) would try to complete a set or put 13 Black Lotus, 13 Ancestral Recall and 13 Lightning Bolts into a deck.

Another thing that was supposed to balance Magic was the existence of Ante. In the original rules, before each game, you and your opponent would remove a random card from your deck before playing, and whoever won would get to keep both cards.

Imagine if Puzzle Quest did the same thing - you put Decimator of the Provinces into your deck and there’s a chance that, not only will the card be removed from the game before playing, but also if you lose the game, you also lose that card forever. Now, a bunch of Lightning Bolts and Healing Salves don’t look so bad when it means you might win your opponent’s Ancestral Recall.

Unfortunately, playing for Ante totally sucked. Nobody enjoyed it. Getting singles back then was like pulling teeth. If you lost a card from your deck, you’d have a heck of a time replacing it. And if you won someone’s random card, you might not have any use for it. Plus, Ante was actually illegal in certain parts of the country. So, they got rid of the concept, banned all Ante cards from every competitive format, and quietly swept the concept under the rug.

One thing to note about Ornithopter and Lotus Petal are that they were actually common cards when first printed. They were reprinted as Super Duper Ultra Rare Masterpieces because they are iconic, and see some competitive play, and when they were first printed, Magic didn’t have fancy schmancy foils or any other way to make an ordinary card “chase”.

In paper Magic, there are quite a few common and uncommon cards which are extremely useful in constructed play. A 75-card Legacy Burn deck, capable of going 5-0 in a competitive tournament might contain as many as 54 commons and basic lands, and not a single Mythic rare. A Modern Tron deck which can take down a tournament might contain 52 commons, uncommons and basic lands.

I’m hopeful that the new tournament structure will allow the developers to experiment with different competitive formats where the determining factor isn’t the size of someone’s wallet but their ability to match gems and sling spells. Once this is achieved, I’m also hopeful that they might loosen up on their silly throttling of the collector’s ability to obtain specific cards. After nearly a year and a half of playing, it should be possible for anyone to have a complete set of Origins, or to simply purchase some elusive card for a reasonable price. It was a mistake for the original Magic developers to think that they could balance power level simply by limiting the print run of a card, and it is a mistake today with the Puzzle Quest version. If Pig is too strong, then Nerf the Pig. But if someone wants to pay good money to buy a copy of pig, I say let them.

There are other games which finance themselves by selling non-game related upgrades. For example, people who pay money might get a foil version of a card or a different skin to play the game on, but spending money doesn’t give them a competitive advantage in the game itself.

We reached the point already where cards that already exist in the game are being reprinted with different art. I don’t know what the right cost would be, but I know that I personally would prefer to see this art for Demolish as opposed to what we already have in the game from Origins.

We also know soon that with Amonkhet we’ll be getting another printing of Evolving Wilds with this art:

This is one I personally find more visually appealing and would prefer to see in my hand as opposed to what we have now.

On top of that we have reprints of commons from Oath of the Gatewatch coming in Amonkhet. These will be cards never seen in the game because they skip the commons from every small set, but that alternate art could be made available for purchase with runes/crystals/a couple real world dollars. These could be small transactions, but are the kind of little things that can add a steady stream of income to the game without actually having to add much more code. Just tell the game to fetch a different art file while the rest of it acts identically.

Thank you. The greatest lesson that MTGPQ could learn is that scarcity does not breed excitement.

Scarcity breeds resentment.

lets compare paper costs since that’s a more accurate look at ROI:

As of this post, the lowest valued paper masterpiece is worth $21.36. If you purchase a booster pack at retail price, it’s still a net profit of over $17.

From Merriam-Webster:
Definition of bonus for English Language Learners
Bonus: something good that is more than what was expected or required
It’s not really a bonus if it’s something you’d just as likely throw away.

Your statement needs more evidence to support it

I should have touched on this before but just because they share a name in the title of the games, does not make them alike. These reasons cannot and do not apply to PQ.
Here’s a quote of my own from MaRo:
“Henry Stern, William Jockusch, and Worth Wollpert (among others) spend countless hours trying to create balanced environments.” (Emphasis my own.)

I agree that it is an interesting article but I disagree with your interpretation. The entire problem here is that they are using M:tG as the content backbone of their match-3 game and yet they are somehow repeating the exact same mistakes that almost killed M:tG 20 years ago. (and, from this poster’s point-of-view, might actually kill M:tGPQ.)

// Removed Attack On Player -Brigby

*Removed comments that were off-topic and non-constructive.

Please keep all comments on track with the topic that was presented in the original post. Thank you!