Fetch failure

Magic: The Gathering - Puzzle Quest MtGPQ Bugs & Technical Issues
1

I had a deck with Danitha Benalia’s Hope, Blade of Shared Souls, and no other Equipment or Auras in it.

Somehow during a game I managed to cast my first Danitha late enough that I had all 4 of my Blade of Shared Souls in the graveyard (along with 7 other cards). (Not 100% sure how they go there but my Planeswalker was Dakkon, and I also played with Overlord of the Floodpits, so there were plenty of ways I could put cards in my graveyard myself even before Greg started doing it for me)

Cast my first Danitha of the game: She failed to fetch a card.
Cast my second Danitha of the game: She failed to fetch a card.

That’s not right, is it? If a card tries to fetch a card from a library, and there are 0 copies of it remaining in your deck currently, then the game should add extra cards to your deck so that it does now contain a legal fetch target. That’s how many other cards in the game work now: Deploy the Gatewatch, for example, in decks with HUF and/or Omni, are capable of playing dozens of copies of Deploy without failing to fetch any cards. Many fetch cards in Legacy are capable of going into infinite loops.

2

I’ve had this happen a few times when I had Assimilation Aegis in my deck. I couldn’t repeat the bug so didn’t report it, but I can validate what you’ve observed.

3

Just had Daxos the Returned’s 1st ability fail to fetch an Enchantment. I’m sure that this is because all the copies of any Enchantments I could have fetched are not currently in my library: I am only playing with one Enchantment (Dollmaker’s Shop), and there are 2 in my Graveyard and 2 in my Exile.

Oh! But on the next turn, when I used Daxos the Returned’s 1st ability, (still with 2 DS in my graveyard and 2 in my exile), the ability did correctly fetch an Enchantment.