I have Turn into a Pumpkin and Bake into Pie in my deck.
I think Turn into a Pumpkin counted towards the food token count, but Baked into a Pie did not. Might be vice versa.
I also used Giant’s Skewer, none of the food tokens created by damaging creatures counted.
There used to be a bug that they all had to be cast in one turn, maybe it came back?
Looks like the bug was never fixed.
The food generated from Trail of Crumbs did not count.
Also, neither the food created by Golden Goose (upon ETB) nor the food tokens created by Gingerbread Cabin counted.
Additional food tokens created by Golden Goose and any tokens created by Feasting Troll King did count.
I will have one more run on that node later tonight.
No, this is definitely not back
I just played a round where all my food tokens counted. So I may have been wrong.