I have been playing a ton of Dowsing Dagger and noticed many bugs with the indestructible weeds it makes.
The main issue seems to be that they are not considered a creature. Ever.
This may be due to how tokens are treated in this game, I’m not sure.
Here’s a list of ways this is impacted:
- Cannot copy with Mirror Image. This was my first goal and then I found out how awful it was. It’s a token though, so I get it.
- Cannot buff the plant unless you specifically target or globally buff it. This became most evident in Battle of the Four Tribes against the 2.2 fight; Tishana, Voice of Thunder. Her first ability is “Elder’s Advice” which is draw a card then your first creature gets +X/+X where X is number of your cards in your hand. She used this many times against me and it never buffed the plant. She was able to buff it other ways, but this had an animation then did nothing.
- Cannot (easily) exile with Isolate. The only way I’ve been able to exile this, because Isolate is indirect, is if they have no other creatures. Even if they have 1 other creature that is a token or has a standard CMC, it ignores the plant until it is the last one. You’d assume it should get exiled first, because tokens have a converted mana cost of 0.
Those seem to be the main ones.